A few weeks ago John Howard, in the face of scary poll results and the admitted threat of electoral annihilation, stated that he did not have a rabbit to pull out of the hat. Well, guess what! He has just found his rabbit. Child abuse in Aboriginal communities is Howard’s rabbit – the Tampa and children overboard rabbit that he has harnessed just 4 months out from the federal election. Of course none of us condone child abuse and all of us want to see it eliminated but WHY HAS HOWARD WAITED TIL NOW TO ACT? Once again Howard’s actions are driven by political strategy. We have seen it with Hicks, climate change, water, and many other issues. As Dr Tim Rowse of the ANU wrote: Recently, we heard through the Prime Minister's leaked analysis of the Government's electoral prospects that he has no 'rabbit to pull out of a hat'. In 2001, when the Howard government needed a rabbit it found one in the alleged 'child abuse' by unauthorised refugees (Children Overboard). The government won a mandate to deal firmly with refugees, and it exercised that mandate, in part, by imprisoning children. Now the government is facing defeat, and it has found -- in the dire circumstances of some Aboriginal communities and families -- the 'rabbit' that it needs. Again, the protection of children will be the Howard team's rallying cry. Today's announcement has the stench of 2001's rotting rabbit carcass.
If there is any doubt about Howard’s belatedness and his tricky strategizing then the following should put the doubt to rest.
Patrick Devery writes on Crikey:
The abuse of children in Indigenous communities is an issue that was highlighted long before Lateline's report in May 2006 initiated the Northern Territory Government's report into the protection of Aboriginal children from sexual abuse. Below is a timeline of how the issue of sexual abuse in Indigenous communities has been publicly addressed.
1989: Judy Atkinson writes a report for the National Inquiry on Violence naming sexual abuse in Indigenous communities as endemic and epidemic.
1991: Ms Atkinson writes a similar report for the Prime Minister and cabinet.
1999: Aboriginal academic Boni Robertson leads an inquiry of 50 women, representing all indigenous communities in Queensland, to look into alcoholism and abuse of women and children in remote communities.
2000: Ms Robertson's report is tabled in the Queensland parliament.
2002: The Central Aboriginal Congress prepares a paper showing the number of Indigenous women being treated for domestic assault at the Alice Springs hospital more than doubled from 351 cases in 1999 to to about 800 cases in 2002.
7 July 2003: Prime Minister John Howard calls a summit on violence in Indigenous communities in response to statements by a number of indigenous leaders. The summit begins on 23 July 2003.
5 August 2003: Cape York community doctor Lara Wieland hands John Howard a 10-page letter outlining incidents of abuse, and claiming that child sexual abuse and neglect are out of control in the community.
26 November 2004: NT Chief Minister Clare Martin reports to a cabinet colleague that "social dysfunction" at central indigenous community Mutitjulu is driven by chemical addiction and passive welfare, and that two-thirds of its children are malnourished or underdeveloped.
15 May 2006: Lateline obtain a confidential briefing paper written by Nanette Rogers, Crown Prosecutor for central Australia. The paper -- originally intended for only a small number of senior police -- details endemic sexual abuse of Aboriginal children in the Northern Territory. Remember how this dominated the media for several weeks!! Where was Howard and his white charger then? (my point in italics)
22 June 2006: The Northern Territory Government announces an inquiry into child sex abuse across the Territory's Aboriginal communities.
8 August 2006: NT Chief Minister, Clare Martin, officially appoints Rex Stephen Leslie Wild QC and Patricia Anderson to the Northern Territory Board of Inquiry into the Protection of Aboriginal Children from Sex Abuse.
30 April 2007: Little Children are Sacred, Report of the Northern Territory Board of Inquiry into the Protection of Aboriginal Children from Sexual Abuse is presented to the Northern Territory government.
16 June 2007: Little Children are Sacred report publicly released.
21 June 2006: Prime Minister John Howard and Indigenous Affairs Minister Mal Brough hold a press conference to announce a series of reforms directed at indigenous communities in the Northern Territory. The Prime Minister calls the situation "akin to a national emergency".
It is disgusting that Howard should compare this situation to Hurricane Katrina when alarm bells have been clanging since the day he became Prime Minister.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I have decided to make a comment on the current Howard shenanegins.
Of course, Howard's up to his old dirty tricks, and could even pull off this new Tampa manoeuvre; but I'm trusting that more of the people will at last see through his latest cynical actions, which he has more cleverly disguised this time as a humanitarian gesture. But it depends on how well he can carry it out. No doubt he should have consulted widely in advance - the Opposition, the States, especially the Northern Territory, the aborigines themselves, the police, the health auuthorities - if his aim was to carry out a successful program to help the aborigines. But, of course, that wasn't his aim; his aim was to win the election. He might just have bungled all this sufficiently to turn the people against him; But if he wins and inevitably makes the situation worse, the election will be over - so who cares?
He hasn't run out of ideas, as Rudd claims. It's just that his ideas are more cynical than ever - designed only for his own electoral advantage. He may come up against aboriginal land rights, as he did once before, and the aborigines themselves may rebel, with sufficient provocation. As for the population as a whole, if Tampa, children overboard, anti-Wik policies, greed, Work Choices, Hansonism, water policies, etc, haven't stirred their consciences, then nothing will. There's no hope of an ethical, compassionate Australia - Australia is wrecked.
The inactivity of the NT government hasn't helped. Carpenter claims that WA has already done more for abos. What? He should be spruiking his successes on the steet corners and from the housetops. Howard rightly says that fereralism is a hindrance. But where was he, under Fraser, when Whitlam came up with a plan to reform it? We wouldn't be stuck in this groove if he had supported that plan.
As for cultural sensitivity, is that the philosophy which not only tolerates, but encourages, aboriginal ill-treatment of women and children (See Herbert's Capricornia) and Moslem repression of women and encouragement of religious intolerance?
From your oldest blog reader (in my 80s)
Post a Comment